Design Dilemma: Balance in an Open-Concept Floor Plan

I’m back today with another reader design dilemma!  Karen writes:

I have an open-concept living and dining room.  I am trying to complete the decor for my dining room and am somewhat at a loss for ideas.  How do I balance these rooms?  Currently one side (the living room) seems heavier than the other.  There is more color in the living area vs. the dining space.  I guess my question would be how and/or what should I bring in to add color in the dining room to balance out this open floor plan .

design dilemma

design dilemma - open floor plan

Open-concept floor plans are great, but they can present some design hurdles.  Creating flow and balance can be a little tough to navigate.  Karen’s already off to a great start!  I think with just a few tweaks she’ll get the design results she’s after.

 

What You Do to One Side, You Should Do To the Other

I’ve been helping my 7th grader with algebra homework lately, so you’ll have to excuse the design parallels I’m drawing upon here.  But just as in an equation, one way to create balance in two separate but joined spaces is in using replication.  Or as we say when solving for x, what you do to one side, you should do to the other.  Karen’s already headed down this path using matching rugs.  I’d say another way to really drive home balance and continuity between these two spaces would be with matching curtain panels.

A few matching statements won’t feel overly redundant, especially in such a large open space, but will really join the spaces together nicely.  I think an always-in-style buffalo check would be beautiful with Karen’s aesthetic, but since they’re isn’t a ton of pattern already in the space, there are lots of alternatives that could work well here.

buffalo check curtain panels

(custom curtain panels)

Balance the Weight

Living spaces as opposed to dining spaces tend to have more furniture in them.  I think in this instance one thing that is throwing Karen off isn’t necessarily color but weight.  The large sectional sofa is much heavier looking than her dining table and chairs.  Looking from the living space into the dining space the matching table and chairs basically makes one statement.  There’s no real visual separation between the pieces of furniture in there.

design dilemma

Two simple ways to add some weight, depth and dimension would be to first swap the end chairs for something taller and slipcovered.

slipcovered dining chair(slipcovered dining chairs)

And second would be to bring in a chandelier over the table creating a nice focal point behind the sofa.

pottery barn chandelier

(chandelier)

The combination of these two design elements/changes would balance the visual weight of the sofa.

Carry the Accent Color Throughout

Typically to create seamless flow from room to room in a home where lots of color is used you would take whatever is used as a main color in one space and use that same color in a smaller dose in the next.  This way every room looks unique yet feels continuous.  In this case since Karen has used a base of neutral toned colors and accented with red tones, I would recommend continuing with that same accent color in the dining room.  A small dose of red goes a long way.  Swapping out the lamps on the buffet with something in red would be the perfect finishing cherry on top.  And since there isn’t much in the way of pattern in here, I’d go with a patterned lamp base for a pop of something unexpected and interesting.

red and white lamp

(colorful lamps)

Bringing It All Together

design dilemma - stacked living and dining space

In addition to the things I mentioned above, I’d also layer the rug in the living space over a larger natural fiber rug to add texture and better ground the size of the sofa.  Lightening up the sofa with some throw pillows in that gorgeous John Robshaw pattern will tie in with the slipcovered chairs and ivory color in the rug.

So what do you think?  Those of you with open-concept floor plans how do you tackle balance in your home?  Do you have any other suggestions for Karen?

Thank you to Karen for submitting a space for this series!  If you have a design dilemma you’d like for me to tackle here on the blog, shoot me an email at Carmel@ourfifthhouse.com with “Design Dilemma” in the subject line.  I’d love to help you brainstorm design ideas!

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

you might also love

  • This was a timely post! I love the changes you made. It really does help to balance out the colors, the feel, and also create a little extra lightness and depth!

    I’m currently trying to figure out what to do to my dining room. They aren’t really connected like the open floor plan here, but instead are separated by the front entrance and staircase. Curtains in the den are ivory, while the ones in my dining room play off the color of my throw pillows along with ivory.

    But the room is so narrow in the dining room that there isn’t space for a buffet to feature other items to create depth and interest, and instead I have a large wall in there with no real decor other than a large black chalkboard.

    But your post already gave me some great ideas of what I should include next.

  • What about painting the dining room wall with the mirror on it? An accent color or subtle pattern might really help if she doesn’t want to swap out the dining chairs.

  • 1. Quick thing I would try is switching the framed print from over the fireplace with the mirror in the dining room. Overall, I thing that the dining room needs some color – this would be a quick way to see if something else on the wall with the mirror would help (the mirror might not be right for over the fireplace, but I think you have to try to see- maybe get something different for the fireplace and use the print in the dining room.

    2. Try adding something on either side of the mirror – botanical prints or something easy to come by. It is possible that that wall may just need more weight.

    2. Something that would require a bit more effort would be to switch the fabric o the cushions of the dining room chairs to something with the burgundy color. Like the idea of bringing the color to the lamps on the credenza but an easier more frugal fix might be to replace the shades with something in that red/burgundy color instead of replacing the entire lamp.

    I love that couch – makes me want to hang out in the room!

  • I love your idea’s and have thought a few might work.
    i will play around with things and see how it looks.
    Thanks again!!!

  • Carmel, great ideas! I think bringing in a chandelier and drapes will go a long way towards balancing the spaces and making the dining room feel a little more substantial. Love your picks!

  • The sources are all linked in the post. Just click on the red text for direct links. This is from Pottery Barn.

  • Great ideas! My first instinct was replace the head dining chairs too. Also quick no cost change would be switching mirror w print overfireplace. The round clock over the doorway and round mirror would bug me…lol

  • I like that the big round mirror ties in with the shape of the coffee table. I’d probably remove the clock before switching the mirror, especially if she does bring in a chandy over the table. I always love the way a chandelier looks being reflected by a mirror. So pretty!

  • Want to be a Fifth House Insider?

    Get the latest updates, exclusive content and behind the scenes photos delivered to your inbox weekly!