Safer Beauty Products – My Makeup Favorites

Years ago on a mission to reclaim my health I made a major change to my diet.  I gave up sodas, fast food and other processed junk food and adopted a new way of living in the hopes that these dietary changes would have a positive effect on my autoimmune thyroid disease.  And positive change did it ever bring.  I witnessed first hand the power and truth behind Hippocrates words, “Let thy food be thy medicine.”  I felt better than I ever had before and discovered that eating real food can absolutely be the best remedy for what ails you.  Who knew it could be that simple?!

My new healthier diet created a bit of a domino effect for me.

I moved away from using toxic chemical-laden household cleaners and brought safe but effective organic cleaners in to my home, incorporating Young Living essential oils as an everyday part of life.

In doing lots of research I learned that 60% of what we put on our skin gets absorbed into our bodies within 26 seconds.  Realizing that my skin is my largest organ, I gave my personal care routine a makeover. After finding out that the European Union has banned close to 1,4oo harmful cosmetic ingredients to the United State’s mere 11 and that companies are allowed to use known toxins without telling us, I ditched my chemically-laden over the counter skin cleansers and moisturizers for safer alternatives.

beautycounter - safer skin

But one area that presented the most difficult change was my makeup bag.  What can I say I’m not a “natural” girl.  I like lipstick, mascara and a good bronzer.  I’d love to be like  – oh hey, I woke up like this.

beautycounter - safer beauty

But those of y’all who follow me on Snapchat know that is hardly the case. (Can I get an Amen for Snapchat filters?!)

The issue I was having in finding safe makeup products was that the “organic”, “all natural” beauty products were rarely effective.  I tried a ton of different, safer brands.  I would have high hopes for lipsticks, foundations and eye shadows only to try them and be less than impressed with the results.  I actually gave up at one point and just conceded the fact that you just can’t get a safe lipstick or a good mascara that will work like those that are full of toxic ingredients.  And I was tired of spending money on safe products that just didn’t get the job done.  I figured well, I tried, but when it came to my makeup bag I wasn’t willing to make any sacrifices.  For goodness sake I already gave up donuts.  Don’t make me give up my lipgloss too.  😉

And then like a beacon of light shining down on my bathroom vanity I stumbled across Beautycounter.

beautycounter - safer beauty

I was like, finally a company that gets that you not only care about a products safety but also about its effectiveness.  Finally a company that makes a lipstick that is not only safe, but one that feels really great on and is long lasting.  Finally a company that is completely transparent in listing every ingredient used in all products.  Finally a company that doesn’t just use marketing terms to create the illusion that their products are safe to use, but one that actually backs up their claims with a 5-step ingredient selection process and has created a never list of ingredients that are known to be harmful that they have pledged to never add to Beautycounter products (many of which are industry standards – shocking as that may be).

Beautycounter Never List

I’ve really fallen in love with Beautycounter, from their philosophy and mission statement to the quality of their products and the beauty of their packaging.  I’ve given my makeup bag a complete Beautycounter overhaul.  Almost everything I use now is Beautycounter with a couple of exceptions.  This is my current make-up squad.

beautycounter - makeup favorites

  1. Dew Skin Tinted Moisturizer  – I’ve found that the older I get the less appealing foundations are to me.  I like something that will make my skin feel really good and provide light coverage.  Anything too heavy just ends up accentuating the fine lines, so I prefer to stick to something light weight.  This tinted moisturizer is great.  It feels wonderful and gives me just enough coverage.  Plus I love that it also has an spf 20 to protect my skin from the sun.
  2.  W3ll People Bio Correct Multi-Action Concealer – I’ve yet to try Beautycounter’s concealer because I’m really in love with this one.  While other W3ll People products didn’t meet the mark for me, this concealer is a really good one.   Great for under the eye area without settling in to the lines.  *One tip with concealer I learned from my time working in the cosmetics industry years ago, is to layer your concealer over your foundation for good coverage.  Most people think you should put it on under your foundation, but you’ll get better coverage if you layer it over the top.  I use it over my tinted moisturizer.
  3. Lustro Shimmer Oil – I’m obsessed with this stuff!   I use all over my face and body for a natural looking bronzed glow.  It gives you that I just got back from the Bahamas look.  I absolutely love it!
  4. Color Sweep Blush Duo – I don’t wear face powder in the summer months, only in the winter when my tan has faded.  In the summer I like to use an all over blush/bronzer.  What I love about Beautycounter blushes is that you get two colors in one compact.  I like the tawny/whisper combo and I use the tawny as an all over bronzer and contour powder and then hit the apples of my cheeks with whisper.
  5. Color Shade Eye Duo   – Again because you get two colors in one these little compacts are so great!  I use the fawn/night combo.  Using the precision brush  I line my eyes with night.  I really love using a powder liner as it defines the eye in a softer way from a pencil liner.  This powder stays in place all day.  A lot of times the safer beauty brands put out muted colors that aren’t very saturated, but Beautycounter’s makeup products were designed by celebrity makeup artist Christy Coleman.  These products were designed to perform.
  6. Lengthening Mascara – Love this!  Defined, lengthened lashes with no clumping or flaking.
  7. Benefit Brow Zings  – This is not a “safe” product.  It actually has a few ingredients from Beautycounter’s never list, but I’ve yet to find a good replacement for it as Beautycounter doesn’t currently have a brow powder.  Filling in your eyebrows, at least for me, makes a world of difference!  I’m kind of big on eyebrows, so I’m going to keep using this until I find a good, safe alternative.  When I find one, I’ll let you know!  Or if you know of one, leave me a comment down below.
  8. Lip Conditioner  – I love this stuff!  It feels amazing on and keeps my lips moisturized so lipstick goes on smoothly.  I wear this all day and put it on again just before bed.  This is a great product to keep on your nightstand.
  9. Lip Sheer – Hands down, this is the best lipstick I’ve ever used.  The name implies a translucent coverage, but while it is lightweight these lipsticks are highly saturated.  You can go with a bold lip or a more natural look depending on the shade you choose and how you want to wear it.  I’m in love with how these lipsticks feel on my lips.  And they stay on so well for being so moisturizing!  Twig and Scarlett are my favorite colors!  Scarlett is the perfect shade of red – not too orange, not too pink.  Lipstick is one of those makeup items that not only goes on the skin but gets ingested being on our lips so finding a good, safe alternative that you don’t have to sacrifice beauty for is so great.  Plus I love the sleek, gold tubes.  Admittedly, the lipsticks are kind of price-y, but I’m telling you  – totally worth it!
  10. Last but not least, Lip Gloss – The only gloss I have is Opal, but I’m planning to add the new shade, fig, to my make-up bag very soon.  It ‘s perfect for fall.

So that’s my current 10 product daily make-up routine.  I love that with Beautycounter I don’t have to sacrifice my health for beauty.  No woman should have to.

Beautycounter - favorite makeup products

I love that this company isn’t just about selling their own safe beauty products. They are actively advocating for more regulations in the cosmetics industry.  This isn’t just a company; this is a movement.  It goes far beyond flawless makeup and into effecting positive change for our daughters, our sons…….our whole country.

Don’t worry, I promise Our Fifth House is not going to turn into a beauty blog!  Though while this blog has mostly been about diy design, I’ve always shared my passions outside of design and decorating here with you all too.  And as so many of you are women I just had to share this awesome movement with you!  As someone who has struggled with an autoimmune disease I’m an advocate for living life as free of toxins as possible.  I’m excited to partner with Beautycounter in their mission of getting safe products into the hands of everyone!

If you want to start switching out some of your beauty products for safer products, Beautycounter makes it really easy to give their products a try with their 60-day return policy.

They also offer a “band of beauty” membership you can sign up for right here, for an annual fee of $25, which includes:

  • Free shipping on orders over $100
  • $25 product credit for every $300 spent with Beautycounter
  • and a savings of 25% on some of Beautycounter’s best selling products

*Just put me – Carmel Phillips – down as your mentor so I can keep you updated with special discounts and sales!  You don’t have to join as a member to shop Beautycounter, although the membership does offer some great perks.

If you’re as passionate about healthy change in our country as I am and want to join as a consultant on my team, email me Carmel@ourfifthhouse.com.  I’d love to talk more with you about this amazing company and movement!

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

you might also love

  • Thanks for sharing. With now both of my daughter’s being diagnosed, as well as myself, with autoimmune thyroid disorders, I am always looking for alternatives that are healthier.

  • Hi Carmel! So excited to see you joined Beautycounter! I am a consultant in NC and love seeing the mission spread! I love every single product and just want to shout from the rooftops how great this line is. Love your blog and loved this post!

  • Hey Abby! So awesome! Thanks! I just love what this company is doing for women and for our country. Excited to be a part of something so wonderful!

  • Yes – Lauren a huge part of why I’ve been so determined to reduce my family’s total toxin load is because I want to keep my children safe and healthy. The idea of them slathering their bodies every day with toxin loaded personal care products just made me sick to my stomach. They deserve better – we all do! I really love BC’s kids line – the shampoo, conditioner and body wash smell wonderful! My son is entering puberty and I just started him on the charcoal soap – it’s been great for his complexion. And I feel good knowing he’s growing up using safer products than I what I grew up using.

  • Nail Polish is a tough one. I’ve tried a few “safer” alternatives. They seem to chip really easily as opposed to the brands we’re all used to seeing and using. Maybe someday Beautycounter will create a good one. There is one brand of polish that is safe alternative I’ve heard good things about online but I’ve yet to try it. The name is escaping me right now, but if I can recall I’ll post the name here.

  • Thank you so much for this post!! I am so looking into this brand!!!

    On a side note- if you don’t mind me asking– which autoimmune thyroid disorder do you and what’s the connection to it with your dietary change/etc.– thanks!!

  • I believe Mineral Fusion, which is sold at Ulta is a brand of nail polish that is ‘better’ for you. I do not know all of the ingredients without a bottle in front of me, but remember a while back while researching that this brand was at least better than the big name ones. Mineral Fusion has a ton of colors. I only own one but it seems to hold up like a regular nail polish would. I have MS so I also have return tried to learn and switch to more natural alternatives.

  • What do you use for deodorant? I made one with baking soda that worked fantastic for a month until I developed a sensitivity to the baking soda.

  • Thanks for the tip on Mineral Fusion. I’ll check them out! Beautycounter is really transparent with their ingredients and their never list is accessible from the website. They even have a pdf pocket printable that you can download from the site and keep in your wallet to make it easier for consumers to look for products without those harmful ingredients. Just clink any of the Beautycounter links in the post to check out their printable never list – it really comes in handy when you’re out shopping!

  • Hi Lisa! Let me know if you have any Beautycounter questions! I’m happy to help you figure out which products you might like to try!

    I was diagnosed with Hashimotos at 24. I was having fertility issues and after having some bloodwork done that’s how my thyroid issues were discovered. It was a long road to getting pregnant and dealing with a variety of symptoms – weight gain, exhaustion, hair loss, mental fog – lots of ups and downs. There is still so much about the thyroid and autoimmune disorders that is unknown, but a friend sent me an article years ago that discussed a link between gluten intolerance and autoimmune disease – specifically thyroid – and that is where my research began. I went gluten free first and noticed a huge improvement…..then ditched grains and dairy and most processed sugars……it was truly amazing what an improvement changing my diet had for me. You can read more about my story under the recipes tab.

  • Hi! I entered the link you posted but I could not find the “band of beauty” $ 25 membership. I just saw the option to become a full member. Help!

  • I was recently diagnosed with Hashimotos too…. and I will certainly look into a gluten free diet- thank you!!

    I love your blog!!! You are so, so talented…..and so real!

    Big fan,
    Lisa

  • Thanks so much Lisa! Sorry to hear about your diagnosis. Thyroid issues are no fun, but yes definitely look in to the link between diet and the thyroid.

  • Carmel-
    Too weird… I was just on the Beautycounter website checking into being a consultant and then hopped over here and just laughed when I saw this post on here. I have Hashimoto’s and since I am so careful about what I put IN my body, I want to be careful about what I put ON my body. Believe it or not, I haven’t even tried the products yet, but I already know that for what they do and offer, that their prices are amazing and I will be hooked. We are in the middle of a complete gut-job so I have been pinching my pennies:) However, skin-care is definitely something I am passionate about and I love taking care of it. I am just nervous to give up my Olay Regenerist Cream because it’s the only son product I have loved and been faithful to over the years. Would love more info on your experience!

  • I love the idea of going chemical free in my makeup and have struggled with finding something that covers my uneven complexion (red cheeks & sunspots). I struggle with the wrinkles on my forehead and the beloved number elevens between my eyes that my foundation exaggerates! Just curious, how does the skin tint even out complexion?

  • It’s wonderful. It provides nice coverage but feels lightweight. But a good makeup application starts with a good skincare routine. I really love what Beautycounter’s skincare products have done for my overall complexion.

  • Want to be a Fifth House Insider?

    Get the latest updates, exclusive content and behind the scenes photos delivered to your inbox weekly!